25 years ago at Winfield College, psycho-priest Zachary Malius murdered seven frat boys and was put away in the local asylum. Now, however, the same fraternity stages a prank from which Malius is inadvertently set free and returns to the house to repeat his crime...
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Nick GregoryEric | Eric |
| LLaura CarneyLiz | Liz |
 Sam RockwellYoung Henry Collins | Young Henry Collins |
 Darren McGavinHenry Collins | Henry Collins |
| CCharles CraginMalius | Malius |
 Frank John HughesSonny | Sonny |
| TTed ClarkNed Bara | Ned Bara |
 Jorja FoxKappa Sig Girl (uncredited) | Kappa Sig Girl (uncredited) |
| LLarry RobinsonOrderly | Orderly |
| LLisa NicholsNurse | Nurse |
 Irfan MensurYoung Father Cane | Young Father Cane |
| EElvis RestainoJake | Jake |
| MMelissa BlanchardCampus Girl | Campus Girl |
| JJeffrey MillerRalph | Ralph |
| DDennis GallantMan in Bar | Man in Bar |
| KKat DelaySusan | Susan |
| SScott BellPete | Pete |
| JJohn AskwithBartender | Bartender |
| WWinston MaySheriff | Sheriff |
| TTatjana PujinKimberly | Kimberly |
 Gala VidenovićMarjorie | Marjorie |
| WWilliam MorrisFrat Boy | Frat Boy |
| LLisa RankineNurse | Nurse |
| CChuck VergaraPatient | Patient |
| KKate HealeyCop | Cop |
 Janez VrhovecFather Cane | Father Cane |
| JJesse Grey WalkenSal (uncredited) | Sal (uncredited) |