A matchmaker connects Molly and Jacob, but their new romance is put to the test when they realize that they are competing deli owners. Will a Hanukkah miracle keep them together?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jeremy JordanJacob | Jacob |
 Yael GrobglasMolly | Molly |
 Linda DarlowRuth | Ruth |
 David EisnerGabe | Gabe |
| LLisa HornerEve | Eve |
| HHarry NelkenStan | Stan |
 Paula ShawEsther | Esther |
 Tim NhlazaneThomas | Thomas |
| SSam RosenthalEd | Ed |
 Lisa LoebNatalie | Natalie |
 Linda E. SmithLiz | Liz |
| AAngela NarthMrs. Mizansky | Mrs. Mizansky |
| CCora MathesonEmo Girl | Emo Girl |
 Darren MartensEzra | Ezra |
 Dan De JaegerFrank | Frank |
| DDebbie MaslowskyGrandmother | Grandmother |
 Henriette IvanansOwner | Owner |
 Jean-Jacques JavierMessenger | Messenger |
 Saul EliasKid | Kid |
| MMariam BernsteinMrs. Rosenbaum | Mrs. Rosenbaum |
| CChristine VetusWaitress | Waitress |
 Frederick AllenCrowd Member (uncredited) | Crowd Member (uncredited) |
 Cindy Rose MyskiwGilbert's Deli Regular (uncredited) | Gilbert's Deli Regular (uncredited) |
 Lorrie PapadopoulosDeli Patron (uncredited) | Deli Patron (uncredited) |
| AAngelica VenancioWaitress | Waitress |
| TTia O'NeillPebbles | Pebbles |
| NNico GentesDonut Boy | Donut Boy |