When Jaime, a self-described "guy's girl," and her boyfriend break up, all of her guy friends simultaneously profess their secret, undying love for her.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| KKavita JariwalaJaime Sharma | Jaime Sharma |
 Katie MuldowneySandy | Sandy |
| JJustin ClarkTed | Ted |
| MMichael DahlgrenPatrick | Patrick |
 Jonathan SmithTerrence (voice) | Terrence (voice) |
| JJames RedfernBradley | Bradley |
 Brett EidmanPhillip | Phillip |
| WWilson ConkwrightRalph | Ralph |
| MMike DrososSimon | Simon |
 Jorge LucasMax | Max |
 Patrick CollinsMr. Vanderbilt | Mr. Vanderbilt |
| GGabrielle FillouxTracy | Tracy |
| JJenyffer ZorrillaWendy | Wendy |
| HHeather ColeGrace | Grace |
| CChloe LewisTricia | Tricia |
| PPhoebe MattanaKate | Kate |
| HHeather ShislerHeather | Heather |
| KKari HustadFilmmaker (voice) | Filmmaker (voice) |
| LLauren SchaffelSophie | Sophie |
| AAlexis IngramCharlotte | Charlotte |
 Karen SummertonJesse | Jesse |
| JJaime Klein-LevinsonAbby | Abby |
| TTara LinhardtRoxy | Roxy |
| MMichele EvansFrankie | Frankie |
| JJacqueline MontroyCaroline | Caroline |
| MMegn BuckleyBeth | Beth |
 Joel SpenceDriver | Driver |
 Nicholas FeitelCustomer | Customer |
| GGabriella Graziano-Lo PrestiCustomer | Customer |
| JJonny SvarzbeinCustomer | Customer |