 Peggy CumminsAnnie Laurie Starr | Annie Laurie Starr |
 John DallBart Tare | Bart Tare |
 Berry KroegerPackett | Packett |
 Morris CarnovskyJudge Willoughby | Judge Willoughby |
 Anabel ShawRuby Tare Flagler | Ruby Tare Flagler |
 Harry LewisSheriff Clyde Boston | Sheriff Clyde Boston |
 Nedrick YoungDave Allister | Dave Allister |
 Trevor BardetteSheriff Boston | Sheriff Boston |
| MMickey LittleBart Tare (Age 7) | Bart Tare (Age 7) |
 Russ TamblynBart Tare (Age 14) | Bart Tare (Age 14) |
| PPaul FrisonClyde Boston (Age 14) | Clyde Boston (Age 14) |
| DDavid BairDave Allister (Child) | Dave Allister (Child) |
 Stanley PragerBluey-Bluey | Bluey-Bluey |
 Virginia FarmerMiss Wynn | Miss Wynn |
| AAnne O'NealMiss Augustine Sifert | Miss Augustine Sifert |
| FFrances IrvinDanceland Singer | Danceland Singer |
 Robert OsterlohHampton Policeman | Hampton Policeman |
 Shimen RuskinCab Driver | Cab Driver |
 Harry HaydenMr. Mallenberg | Mr. Mallenberg |
| JJohn AlbanOffice Worker (uncredited) | Office Worker (uncredited) |
| TTony BarrProprietor / Diner Cook (uncredited) | Proprietor / Diner Cook (uncredited) |
 Don BeddoeChicago Man (uncredited) | Chicago Man (uncredited) |
 Joseph CrehanPlant Foreman (uncredited) | Plant Foreman (uncredited) |
 Eddie DunnState Policeman on Phone (uncredited) | State Policeman on Phone (uncredited) |
 Dick ElliottMan Fleeing Robbed Market (uncredited) | Man Fleeing Robbed Market (uncredited) |
 Ross ElliottDetective (uncredited) | Detective (uncredited) |
 Franklyn FarnumCashier (uncredited) | Cashier (uncredited) |
| KKay GarrettCarnival Patron (uncredited) | Carnival Patron (uncredited) |
 Pat GleasonCarnival Barker (uncredited) | Carnival Barker (uncredited) |
| JJames GonzalezDance Hall Patron (uncredited) | Dance Hall Patron (uncredited) |
