 Ryan Scott ThomasMr. Burke | Mr. Burke |
| DD. Patrick BauerAl (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") | Al (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") |
| JJohn Latchford BeckThe Shopkeeper (as John Beck) | The Shopkeeper (as John Beck) |
 Leanna ChamishPaula (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") | Paula (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") |
| MMike BaldwinCarl (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Carl (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |
| KKelly CostonJanice (segment "Last Kill and Testament") | Janice (segment "Last Kill and Testament") |
| LLee DollDr. Weinberg (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Dr. Weinberg (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |
| AAJ HydePatrick (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Patrick (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |
| SShane ElliottMummy | Mummy |
| FFred HahnRobert Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") | Robert Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") |
| LLindsay HansonVictorian Vixen (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Victorian Vixen (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |
 Jimmy GeorgeBenjamin Porter (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") | Benjamin Porter (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") |
| VVirginia HouseSusan Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") (as Virginia Frank) | Susan Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") (as Virginia Frank) |
| MMark J. KilbaneRoger (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") | Roger (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") |
 Chris LaMartinaDante (segment "Last Kill and Testament") | Dante (segment "Last Kill and Testament") |
| MMary Fay LaMartinaMother (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Mother (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |
| JJustin LanhamGhost (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") | Ghost (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") |
| SSheldon LawrenceProfessor Gauntheim (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") | Professor Gauntheim (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") |
 Cindy Marie MartinNadine (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") | Nadine (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") |
| BBrian Fountain MurrayBrady (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") | Brady (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") |
| MMary Jane OelkeMs. Bennett (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") | Ms. Bennett (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams") |
| JJess OwenVampire (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Vampire (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |
| VVince SaulsburyVampire Expert (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Vampire Expert (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |
| CChris StewartStory Heroine (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") | Story Heroine (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales") |
 George StoverAlan Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") | Alan Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") |
| FFrank VinceChazz Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") | Chazz Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") |
| BBernie WamhoffMilton (segment "Last Kill and Testament") | Milton (segment "Last Kill and Testament") |
| MMyke WellsTerry (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Terry (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |
| RRandi WilliamsVampire Food (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") | Vampire Food (segment "Sleep When You're Undead") |