Otto Wall is just a little unlucky in life, and unbeknownst to him, in love. When his wife suddenly asks for a divorce, he bounces between a search for answers, desperate attempts to stay connected to his daughter, and his fateful reentry into the dating pool.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Paul SchneiderOtto Wall | Otto Wall |
 Anna CampDebbie Spangler | Debbie Spangler |
 Michael ChernusFreddie | Freddie |
 Heather GrahamStephanie | Stephanie |
 Ashley HinshawMildred | Mildred |
 Heather LawlessLara | Lara |
 Melanie LynskeyAnnie Wall | Annie Wall |
 Audrey P. ScottEdie Wall | Edie Wall |
 Amy SedarisHolly | Holly |
 Celia WestonJoan | Joan |
 Steve CoulterLawyer | Lawyer |
| RRobert HaulbrookReal Estate Broker | Real Estate Broker |
| MMelcher SmithDick | Dick |
| SSteven HallDoctor | Doctor |
| JJeffrey Dean FosterGreeter at Church | Greeter at Church |
| BBeth BosticGinny | Ginny |
| BBen BakerForgotten Man at Reunion (Richard Watts) | Forgotten Man at Reunion (Richard Watts) |
| PPatrice D’EvansLiz | Liz |
| MMabel RobinsonLiz’s Mother | Liz’s Mother |
| SSally MeehanStoryteller at Reunion | Storyteller at Reunion |