Four families and a chief of police recount the day marine casualty officers came to their respective small towns in Ohio.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Michael StuhlbargThe Interviewer | The Interviewer |
 Adam DriverJared Rock | Jared Rock |
 Michael EmersonSteve Harper | Steve Harper |
 Bill IrwinChief Jeff 'Goob' Garver | Chief Jeff 'Goob' Garver |
 Alison PillKendra Harper | Kendra Harper |
| MMelissa HurstJanet Harper | Janet Harper |
 Elizabeth MarvelEdie Deyarmin | Edie Deyarmin |
| GGarrett NeergaardTyler Hoffman | Tyler Hoffman |
 Mercedes RuehlAdriana Rock | Adriana Rock |
 Brenda WehleCarole Hoffman | Carole Hoffman |