 Bing CrosbyFather Chuck O'Malley | Father Chuck O'Malley |
 Barry FitzgeraldFather Fitzgibbon | Father Fitzgibbon |
 Frank McHughFather Timothy O'Dowd | Father Timothy O'Dowd |
 James BrownTed Haines Jr. | Ted Haines Jr. |
 Gene LockhartTed Haines Snr. | Ted Haines Snr. |
 Jean HeatherCarol James | Carol James |
 Porter HallMr. Belknap | Mr. Belknap |
 Fortunio BonanovaTomaso Bozanni | Tomaso Bozanni |
 Eily MalyonMrs. Carmody | Mrs. Carmody |
 Risë StevensGenevieve Linden | Genevieve Linden |
| AArnet AmosSinger (uncredited) | Singer (uncredited) |
 Stanley ClementsTony Scaponi (uncredited) | Tony Scaponi (uncredited) |
 Adeline De Walt ReynoldsMrs. Molly Fitzgibbon (uncredited) | Mrs. Molly Fitzgibbon (uncredited) |
 Tom DillonPolice Officer Pat McCarthy (uncredited) | Police Officer Pat McCarthy (uncredited) |
| BBobby Dolan Jr.Joseph (uncredited) | Joseph (uncredited) |
| JJimmie DundeeFireman (uncredited) | Fireman (uncredited) |
 Virginia FarmerParishioner (uncredited) | Parishioner (uncredited) |
 Franklyn FarnumChurch Usher (uncredited) | Church Usher (uncredited) |
 William FrawleyMax Dolan, Publisher (uncredited) | Max Dolan, Publisher (uncredited) |
| DDon GallaherMan (uncredited) | Man (uncredited) |
 Martín GarralagaZuñiga (uncredited) | Zuñiga (uncredited) |
 Julie GibsonCab Driver (uncredited) | Cab Driver (uncredited) |
 Gibson GowlandParishioner (uncredited) | Parishioner (uncredited) |
 William HenryDoctor (uncredited) | Doctor (uncredited) |
| CConnie LeonMrs. Quimp's Neighbor (uncredited) | Mrs. Quimp's Neighbor (uncredited) |
 Sybil LewisEffie, Genevieve's Maid (uncredited) | Effie, Genevieve's Maid (uncredited) |
 Hugh MaguirePitch Pipe (uncredited) | Pitch Pipe (uncredited) |
| WWilliam MarionParishioner (uncredited) | Parishioner (uncredited) |
 George McKayMr. Van Heusen (uncredited) | Mr. Van Heusen (uncredited) |
 Freddie MercerBoys Choir Member (uncredited) | Boys Choir Member (uncredited) |
