In modern-day New York City, John the Baptist calls out to a group of young men and women to learn from the teachings of Jesus. Through song and dance, they relive Christ's crucifixion.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Victor GarberJesus | Jesus |
 Katie HanleyKatie | Katie |
 David HaskellJohn / Judas | John / Judas |
| MMerrell JacksonMerrell | Merrell |
| JJoanne JonasJoanne | Joanne |
 Robin LamontRobin | Robin |
 Gilmer McCormickGilmer | Gilmer |
 Jeffrey MylettJeffrey | Jeffrey |
 Jerry SrokaJerry | Jerry |
 Lynne ThigpenLynne | Lynne |
 John-Michael TebelakPharisee Monster (voice) | Pharisee Monster (voice) |