 Sean AstinNarrator | Narrator |
 Mallory EvertonCora / Townswoman | Cora / Townswoman |
| WWhitney CallRobert Failure Gladstone / Charlotte / Temperance | Robert Failure Gladstone / Charlotte / Temperance |
 Matthew MeeseCaptain Evander Lillianquist / Willy / Flour Man / Jeff | Captain Evander Lillianquist / Willy / Flour Man / Jeff |
 Jason GrayChesterton / Doctor / Proprietor / Kit Carson | Chesterton / Doctor / Proprietor / Kit Carson |
 Natalie MadsenAveline / Madam Molly | Aveline / Madam Molly |
| SStephen MeekElijah / William / Thirsty Man | Elijah / William / Thirsty Man |
 Stacey HarkeyTerrence / Clarence / Fan #2 / The Ringmaster | Terrence / Clarence / Fan #2 / The Ringmaster |
 Jeremy WarnerHank / The Lion | Hank / The Lion |
| AAdam BergPercival / Polio Joe / Henry / Billy / Mime | Percival / Polio Joe / Henry / Billy / Mime |
 James PerryAngus / Julian / Johnny River / Fan #1 / Porch Man / Papa | Angus / Julian / Johnny River / Fan #1 / Porch Man / Papa |
 Matt MoenStrongman | Strongman |
| RRuth ClarkeJohnny River Sr. | Johnny River Sr. |
| MMolly SchofieldSarah Jenkins | Sarah Jenkins |
| MMacy KnappTeen Aveline | Teen Aveline |
| MMiley KnappYoung Aveline | Young Aveline |
| SSonja CallGrandma Jenkins | Grandma Jenkins |
| AAlan CallGrandpa Jenkins | Grandpa Jenkins |
| CCruz JolleyJenkins Boy | Jenkins Boy |
| AAsher ChappellGlenn the Ranch Hand | Glenn the Ranch Hand |
| CChris DwightAssassin | Assassin |
 Bryson AlejandroSimon Bolivar | Simon Bolivar |
| CChase MontierthPoor Chap Elijah Refused to Carry Across the River | Poor Chap Elijah Refused to Carry Across the River |
| LLorymore WarnerFirst-born Son | First-born Son |
