After Emily returns home years after her childhood abduction, her sister Lily and parents are overjoyed. But unsettling occurrences make Lily wonder if the nightmare is really over.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Rylee ReaganLily Tanner | Lily Tanner |
 Isabella CarlsenEmily Tanner | Emily Tanner |
 Chelsea GilsonKate Tanner | Kate Tanner |
 Jon Eric HoffmanMatt Tanner | Matt Tanner |
 Phil TalamontiJohn Norris | John Norris |
 Charlotte BanksDee | Dee |
 Victoria CabralCafe Patron | Cafe Patron |
 Jessica DeBonvilleNaomi Ackerman | Naomi Ackerman |
 Alfred Lamar Pierce IIOfficer Bowen | Officer Bowen |
 Lisha HackneyDr. Salazar | Dr. Salazar |