A small town comes under the thumb of Martha, a ghost who returns to haunt the children who witnessed her death during a "game" of Ghost in the Graveyard as young children.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kelli BerglundSally Sullivan | Sally Sullivan |
 Jake BuseyCharlie Sullivan | Charlie Sullivan |
 Olivia LarsenZoe | Zoe |
 Royce JohnsonSheriff D. | Sheriff D. |
 Maria OlsenThe Witch | The Witch |
 Nikki BlonskyMrs. E | Mrs. E |
 Jason James RichterDeputy T | Deputy T |
 Shifra ZuckermanDonna • Sidekick | Donna • Sidekick |
 Grace NarducciKaren • Sidekick | Karen • Sidekick |
 Joseph D'OnofrioDeputy Simmons | Deputy Simmons |
 Zebedee RowBilly Sullivan | Billy Sullivan |
| RRiley VictoriaJade • Junior Sidekick | Jade • Junior Sidekick |
| JJacqueline VenéLaura | Laura |
| KKylie KissLittle Zoe | Little Zoe |
| MMary AnisiSister Brigit | Sister Brigit |
| FFaye GiordanoLittle Sally | Little Sally |