A perpetually miserable man finds happiness when he starts dating a manic pixie dream girl, to the befuddlement of his cynical best friend.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Chris RiggiCharlie | Charlie |
 Adam LaVorgnaBobby | Bobby |
 Rebecca BlumhagenAbby | Abby |
 Jordan Lane PriceSarah | Sarah |
 Lauren SweetserHolly | Holly |
| RRobert Sean MillerMr. Spencer | Mr. Spencer |
| SSamantha EggersVictoria | Victoria |
 Breanna LakatosMary | Mary |