 Karen GillanRachel Milligan (segment 'Conventional') | Rachel Milligan (segment 'Conventional') |
 Matty CardaropleStu Mac 1 (segment 'Conventional') | Stu Mac 1 (segment 'Conventional') |
 James RansoneStu Mac 3 (segment 'Conventional') | Stu Mac 3 (segment 'Conventional') |
 Tracie ThomsTommy (segment 'Playing Dead') | Tommy (segment 'Playing Dead') |
 Paul TelferReggie (segment 'Playing Dead') | Reggie (segment 'Playing Dead') |
 Megan DuffyMelissa (segment 'Pinned') | Melissa (segment 'Pinned') |
 Adi ShankarDex (segment 'Playing Dead') | Dex (segment 'Playing Dead') |
 Ryan TurekOriginal Stu Mac (segment 'Conventional') | Original Stu Mac (segment 'Conventional') |
 Diva ZappaAudience Member (segment 'Last Laugh') | Audience Member (segment 'Last Laugh') |
 Justin GordonEvan (segment 'Pinned') | Evan (segment 'Pinned') |
| MMali ElfmanLisa (segment 'Perfect') | Lisa (segment 'Perfect') |
| LLara SebastianEmma (segment 'Conventional') | Emma (segment 'Conventional') |
| AAmy SchloerbAudience Member (segment 'Last Laugh') | Audience Member (segment 'Last Laugh') |
| MMichael MayStu Mac 2 (segment 'Conventional') | Stu Mac 2 (segment 'Conventional') |
| TTrey EverettJosh (segment 'Perfect') | Josh (segment 'Perfect') |
| JJake VartaJoe (segment 'Playing Dead') | Joe (segment 'Playing Dead') |
| AAndrew FurtadoCorbin (segment 'The Great Corbin') | Corbin (segment 'The Great Corbin') |
 Skylar RobergeGrace (segment "Kill Them Mommy") | Grace (segment "Kill Them Mommy") |
 Kari CalhounDevon (segment "Kill Them Mommy") | Devon (segment "Kill Them Mommy") |
| HHayley CrispDolores (segment "Kill Them Mommy") | Dolores (segment "Kill Them Mommy") |
 Anthony KirlewMalcolm (segment "Prey") | Malcolm (segment "Prey") |
| LLucas ChampagneRicky (segment "Prey") | Ricky (segment "Prey") |
| JJustin MokayedSeth (segment "Prey") | Seth (segment "Prey") |
| SSam UehlingJake (segment "Prey") | Jake (segment "Prey") |
 Josh ElliottMan (segment "Whispers") | Man (segment "Whispers") |