At a Fire Island Christmas reunion party, three guys recall their three versions of the events that happened at Cherry Grove the previous summer.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Larry PageRon Remena | Ron Remena |
| JJohn CarloRick Johnson | Rick Johnson |
 Hugh AllenGreg | Greg |
 Garry HuntJeff Holt | Jeff Holt |
 Chris MichaelsTerry Caswell | Terry Caswell |
 Will SeagersLeslie Vickers | Leslie Vickers |
| PPepe BrazilGeorge's trick | George's trick |
| GGeorge SardiParty host | Party host |
| DDavid LittlerNot listed | Not listed |
| FFrank SchmittNot listed | Not listed |
| JJohnny SavoyNot listed | Not listed |