May 28, 2005 from The Hernando County Fairgrounds in Brooksville, Florida
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Phil BrooksCM Punk | CM Punk |
 Nuufolau Joel SeanoaNot listed | Not listed |
 Scott ColtonColt Cabana | Colt Cabana |
 Salvatore RinauroSal Rinauro | Sal Rinauro |
| NNelson Rodriguez ErazoHomicide | Homicide |
 Walter KirneyAzrieal | Azrieal |
 Christopher LindseyRoderick Strong | Roderick Strong |
 Charles SpencerTony Mamaluke | Tony Mamaluke |
 Eddie Villa"Fast" Eddie Vegas | "Fast" Eddie Vegas |
| JJay FuryJay Fury | Jay Fury |
 Kory ChavisRainman | Rainman |
 Edward WalkerVordell Walker | Vordell Walker |
| EEvan StarsmoreEvan Starsmore | Evan Starsmore |
 Steve FavataSteve Madison | Steve Madison |
| AAaron EpicAaron Epic | Aaron Epic |
 Phil Davis"Fabulous" Phil Davis | "Fabulous" Phil Davis |
 Sean Davis"Superstar" Sean Davis | "Superstar" Sean Davis |
 Chris ValenzuelaDon Juan | Don Juan |
| CChris MarvelChris Marvel | Chris Marvel |
 Jerrelle ClarkJerrelle Clark | Jerrelle Clark |
| JJared SteeleJared Steele | Jared Steele |
 Dave PrazakDave Prazak (Manager) | Dave Prazak (Manager) |