Faith-fueled friends Muggles and Joy visit the beautiful Finding Jesus Bay, a place where Christian stories are told night and day. Guided by the sea's best storyteller, Professor Shark, they hear all about the endless kindness and boundless love of their Creator. Then, together, they go forth to spread His word, and make their world a better place.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| SSarah TaylorMuggles / Delfi / Scales / Snaps (voice) | Muggles / Delfi / Scales / Snaps (voice) |
| AAngie GillespieJoy (voice) | Joy (voice) |
 KJ SchrockProfessor Shark / Mr. Sushi (voice) | Professor Shark / Mr. Sushi (voice) |
| VVictor MerchanScary Henry (voice) | Scary Henry (voice) |
 Darren RichardsonPickles (voice) | Pickles (voice) |
| LLizzy Carter-BurnsFizzy (voice) | Fizzy (voice) |