Over the course of an app date, Matt tells the story of his "Fellas," and the scandal they get into when a problematic DVD box set goes missing at their housewarming.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Matthew Danger LippmanMatthew | Matthew |
| MMatt AllanMarty | Marty |
| WWill BrownWill | Will |
| NNick NewmanNick | Nick |
 Greer CohenJenna | Jenna |
 Elsie FisherHannah | Hannah |
 Betsey BrownMelinda | Melinda |
| AAllison BermanCassandra | Cassandra |
| JJack WeissTodd | Todd |
| MMichelle MoriartyBlaire | Blaire |
 Ron Farrar BrownBlaire's Dad | Blaire's Dad |
 Jane BrownBlaire's Mom | Blaire's Mom |
 Lawrence ArancioSheldon | Sheldon |
| CCyprian MaronaKratom Trent | Kratom Trent |
| MMichael BernieriHaving a Problem Party Guest | Having a Problem Party Guest |
| RRenee Nicole PowellJasmine | Jasmine |
 Mia ValletAndrea | Andrea |
| KKayla MarcusPorno Actress | Porno Actress |
| GGabriel RysdahlPorno Actor | Porno Actor |
 Al NazemianDoorman | Doorman |