A skeptical journalist is assigned to chronicle the 50th anniversary of Kris Kringle, a Santa Claus in the town of Mistletoe. As her involvement in the town grows, she begins to open up to the enchantment of Christmas and some other wonders of the season.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Christine TaylorAnnabelle Wahl | Annabelle Wahl |
 William Morgan SheppardKris Kringle | Kris Kringle |
 Christopher WiehlMark Stafford | Mark Stafford |
 Lin ShayeZelda | Zelda |
 Shashawnee HallMayor Phil Green | Mayor Phil Green |
 Michael ChieffoHank | Hank |
 Vivica A. FoxZoe Marsden | Zoe Marsden |
| TTony CicchettiJake | Jake |
 John FarleyLloyd | Lloyd |
 Joshua SnyderBrian Wahl | Brian Wahl |
 Angela PierceDr. Nora | Dr. Nora |
 John KapelosHarley | Harley |
 Katy StollCarly | Carly |
 Kristin BurkeBetty Anne Clark | Betty Anne Clark |
 Jonathan SpencerJonathan | Jonathan |
| LLaura NiemiEmily | Emily |
 Chris FarahSarah | Sarah |
 Tate BerneyOwen | Owen |