At the height of her career, investigative journalist Hannah Dunbar finds herself wondering what would have been had she stayed with the love of her life, Ben, 10 years before. When Santa Claus hears her “what ifs?” as a Christmas wish, he transports Hannah to a version of her life where she and Ben started a family.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lacey ChabertHannah Dunbar | Hannah Dunbar |
 Tyron LeitsoBen Matthews | Ben Matthews |
 Matthew Kevin AndersonGrant Walker | Grant Walker |
 Brittney WilsonCarrie Garrett | Carrie Garrett |
 Jill MorrisonTammy Frink | Tammy Frink |
 Keith MacKechnieSanta Clause | Santa Clause |
 James KirkCarl Oxley | Carl Oxley |
 Milli WilkinsonCaitlin | Caitlin |
 Audrey SmallmanHallie | Hallie |
 Michael St. John SmithHarold Wainright | Harold Wainright |
 Michael MeneerAnchor Man | Anchor Man |
| DDanny MacRob Frink | Rob Frink |
 Laura AdkinMary Beth Harvey | Mary Beth Harvey |
 Lee TichonSecurity Guard | Security Guard |
| KKat KarpoffSheila | Sheila |
 Chris NowlandStuart | Stuart |
| MMichael BeanWaiter | Waiter |
 Aaron HutchinsonSuburban Man | Suburban Man |
 Allyson GrantStroller Mom | Stroller Mom |