 Elliott GouldHarry Lewis (Present Day) | Harry Lewis (Present Day) |
 Susannah YorkSue Lewis (Present Day) | Sue Lewis (Present Day) |
 Kaye BallardMrs. Lewis (1940's) | Mrs. Lewis (1940's) |
| SStuart Paul'Pompadoure' (Young Harry Lewis) (1940's) | 'Pompadoure' (Young Harry Lewis) (1940's) |
 Michelle PfeifferSue Wellington (1940's) | Sue Wellington (1940's) |
| RRobert HackmanMr. Lewis (1940's) | Mr. Lewis (1940's) |
 Herbert RudleyMr. Wellington (1940's) | Mr. Wellington (1940's) |
 Marian McCargoMrs. Wellington (1940's) | Mrs. Wellington (1940's) |
 Steven PaulStan the Con (1940's) | Stan the Con (1940's) |
 Tallie CochraneHooker (Present Day) | Hooker (Present Day) |
 Patrick WrightPat the Cop (1940's) | Pat the Cop (1940's) |
| BBonnie PaulHilary Lewis (Present Day) | Hilary Lewis (Present Day) |
 Tony O'DellDonny Lewis (Present Day) | Donny Lewis (Present Day) |
 Ben FrankCabbie #1 (Present Day) | Cabbie #1 (Present Day) |
 John DiehlBeaver (1940's) | Beaver (1940's) |
 David CarusoNeighborhood boy (uncredited) | Neighborhood boy (uncredited) |
 Pete SchrumMeatloaf (Present Day) | Meatloaf (Present Day) |
| MMarvin KatzoffComo (1940's) | Como (1940's) |
| AAlan SolomonMax the Brain (1940's) | Max the Brain (1940's) |
| DDaniel DaviesMeatloaf (1940's) | Meatloaf (1940's) |
| MMickey CherneyBen Herman (1940's) | Ben Herman (1940's) |
| MMort SchwartzHymie the Bookie (1940's) | Hymie the Bookie (1940's) |
| AAl BordighiComo's Father (1940's) | Como's Father (1940's) |
 Twink CaplanMalinda (1940's) | Malinda (1940's) |
| SShel GoldsteinScrap Drive Leader - 1940's | Scrap Drive Leader - 1940's |
| WWalter G. ZeriTough Guy | Tough Guy |
| MMickey GatlinCabbie #2 (Present Day) | Cabbie #2 (Present Day) |
 Terrence EvansBeaver (Present Day) | Beaver (Present Day) |
