Christmas lover Lori Jo and her roommate head to Yuletide Springs for a longtime tradition to honor her late grandmother — and meet two men, Carl and Jason, along the way.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Cindy BusbyLori Jo "LJ" | Lori Jo "LJ" |
 Corey SevierZach | Zach |
 Katherine BarrellVictoria "Tory" | Victoria "Tory" |
 Matt WellsJason | Jason |
 George MasswohlKris Kringle | Kris Kringle |
 Ruth LawrencePastor Olivia | Pastor Olivia |
 Chuck HerriottMayor Bennett | Mayor Bennett |
| AAva KaneCindy | Cindy |
 Jana GillisJulia | Julia |
 Andrew HallidayRyan | Ryan |
| CClint Chima KaluPostal Clerk | Postal Clerk |
| HHarvey HeathStore Owner | Store Owner |
| JJim LesterCarriage Driver | Carriage Driver |