One clear summer day in a Baltimore suburb, a baby goes missing from her front porch. Two young girls serve seven years for the crime and are released into a town that hasn't fully forgiven or forgotten. Soon, another child is missing, and two detectives are called in to investigate the mystery in a community where everyone seems to have a secret.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Diane LaneHelen Manning | Helen Manning |
 Elizabeth BanksDetective Nancy Porter | Detective Nancy Porter |
 Dakota FanningRonnie Fuller | Ronnie Fuller |
 Danielle MacdonaldAlice Manning | Alice Manning |
 Nate ParkerDetective Kevin Jones | Detective Kevin Jones |
 CommonDevlin Hatch | Devlin Hatch |
 Colin DonnellPaul Porter | Paul Porter |
 Bill SageDave Fuller | Dave Fuller |
 Renée Elise GoldsberryCynthia Barnes | Cynthia Barnes |
| BBrynne NorquistYoung Alice Manning | Young Alice Manning |
| EEva Grace KellnerYoung Ronnie Fuller | Young Ronnie Fuller |
 Clare FoleyMary Paige | Mary Paige |
 Jack GoreTommy | Tommy |
 Skylar GaertnerJimmy (uncredited) | Jimmy (uncredited) |