Barnabetta Dreary's grim life of slaving for her Pennsylvania Dutch father Barnaby and her two brothers, is surprisingly changed when Barnaby marries Juliet Miller. Known as Erstwhile Susan, she becomes fond of Barnabetta, and because she retains control of her fortune, induces the other Drearys to relieve Barnabetta of some of her drudgery.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Constance BinneyBarnabetta Dreary | Barnabetta Dreary |
 Jere AustinDavid Jordan | David Jordan |
 Alfred HickmanDr. Edgar Barrett | Dr. Edgar Barrett |
 Mary AldenErstwhile Susan | Erstwhile Susan |
 Anders RandolfBarnaby Dreary | Barnaby Dreary |
 Georges RenaventEmanual Dreary | Emanual Dreary |
 Bradley BarkerJacob Dreary | Jacob Dreary |
| LLeslie HuntAlbert Buchter | Albert Buchter |