On the 20th anniversary of the gruesome Christmas Eve murders at St. Agnes church, a demonic preacher returns to haunt that same town's residents.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Eric RobertsDr. Rockeby | Dr. Rockeby |
 Doug JonesLester | Lester |
 Alexis KnappKarisma | Karisma |
 Brittany CarelCharlotte | Charlotte |
 David SteenMr. Monday | Mr. Monday |
 Erin MatthewsSister Agnes | Sister Agnes |
 Greg KriekRed | Red |
 Bai LingMadam Thorn | Madam Thorn |
 Christopher LivingstoneBandini | Bandini |
 Hutch DanoDaryl | Daryl |
 Anna GreeneJewels | Jewels |
 Diane RobinGhost Mother's Voice | Ghost Mother's Voice |
| WWilliam Troy FordLittle Red | Little Red |
| SSpyder DobrofskySalem | Salem |
| DDidi AlaouiThe Prankster | The Prankster |
| ZZhengzhao YangMonty | Monty |
| HHarry HermanBernard | Bernard |
| MMary DeMatteoThorn's Girl | Thorn's Girl |
| MMarla CempnerSalem's Mother | Salem's Mother |
 Luke MullenChurch Charlie | Church Charlie |
| CClay LaceyConcerned Churchgoer | Concerned Churchgoer |
| DDanny HackinFerry | Ferry |
| JJaclyn AlbergoniMarisol | Marisol |
| DDaniel Evan RogoveDirty Dan | Dirty Dan |
| QQiang DongThorn's Security Guard | Thorn's Security Guard |
| AAndrew OberlanderMilk Store Patron | Milk Store Patron |