Two guys who make a pact to lose their virginity before prom find their friendship tested when one of them comes out of the closet.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Nicholas BraunMichael | Michael |
 Hunter CopeMatty | Matty |
 Dakota JohnsonEm | Em |
 Zach CreggerGreg | Greg |
 Nick OffermanTerry | Terry |
 Gary ColeDwayne | Dwayne |
 Megan MullallyPatricia | Patricia |
 Sarah HylandAva | Ava |
 Brian GeraghtyLars | Lars |
 Rob HuebelPete | Pete |
 Wendi McLendon-CoveyLinda | Linda |
 Aziz AnsariMarcus | Marcus |
 Dustin YbarraJosh | Josh |
 Adam DiMarcoJared | Jared |
 Larry WilmoreMr. Vernon | Mr. Vernon |
 Ray SantiagoSalvadore | Salvadore |
 Luis JavierEdgar | Edgar |
 Cainan WiebeFrederick | Frederick |
| HHailey WiebeRuth | Ruth |
 Samuel Patrick ChuAnthony | Anthony |
 William VaughanChris | Chris |
 Harris AllanDan | Dan |
| HHarrison MacDonaldMark | Mark |
 Bryce HodgsonBlake | Blake |
 Dreama WalkerNicole | Nicole |
 Quinn LordMichael (8 Years) | Michael (8 Years) |
 Darien ProvostMatty (8 Years) | Matty (8 Years) |