 James MurrayJudas | Judas |
| JJeremy GuskinJesus | Jesus |
| RRonney AscherManuel Hossenfeffer Rodriguez | Manuel Hossenfeffer Rodriguez |
| MMarti CooneyMrs. Baker / Hoagie Woman | Mrs. Baker / Hoagie Woman |
| LLaurence FrommerMr. Baker | Mr. Baker |
| EElizabeth WoodMary / Disgusted Angel | Mary / Disgusted Angel |
| DDavid SkigenJoseph | Joseph |
 Sal VulcanoLawn Mower Boy / Extra | Lawn Mower Boy / Extra |
| MMatthew GlassLarry | Larry |
| HHank PojeJames Peterson / God / Smitty | James Peterson / God / Smitty |
| JJonah ZeigerVinny (as Jonah Zieger) | Vinny (as Jonah Zieger) |
 Kelley Rae O'DonnellPlay Angel | Play Angel |
| DDavid HubbellHerbie Falafen | Herbie Falafen |
| JJames P. MurrayGeorge | George |
| LLino AlvarezDr. Puglia / Yelling Angel | Dr. Puglia / Yelling Angel |
| PPete BarkerMoses | Moses |
| KKen DrayNoah | Noah |
| DDennis MeehanHam Slicing Boy | Ham Slicing Boy |
| HHillary Ayn RyanSandy Weinberg (as Hillary Gouse) | Sandy Weinberg (as Hillary Gouse) |
| LLyle SilversmithMax Weinberg | Max Weinberg |
| JJason HomEzekiel Weinberg | Ezekiel Weinberg |
| JJonathan BeatriceScared Angel | Scared Angel |
| CColin LianderRoman Centurion / Extra | Roman Centurion / Extra |
| MMichael RigbyRoman Centurion | Roman Centurion |
| PPatrick NicholasSatan | Satan |
| CChristopher MorganBar Wiping Boy | Bar Wiping Boy |
| BBennato PennellaBar Tender Assistant | Bar Tender Assistant |
| AAndrew HanniffyExtra | Extra |
| BBrian J. JamiesonExtra | Extra |
| GGlenn KleinExtra | Extra |
