Four friends wake on Halloween and realize the predict-your-future game they played in 2002 is coming true in disturbing ways. They must band together to help each other escape the wild fates that have turned their lives upside down.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jessica LoweErica Greenspan | Erica Greenspan |
 Harvey GuillénAndy | Andy |
 Nicole ByerMikayla | Mikayla |
 Andrew Lewis CaldwellJosh Greenspan | Josh Greenspan |
 Joey FatoneJoey Fatone | Joey Fatone |
 Rob RiggleMr. Knight | Mr. Knight |
 James Austin JohnsonJeremy Fischbein | Jeremy Fischbein |
 Kathy GriffinStacy Friendship | Stacy Friendship |
 Nikki GlaserPhoebe Schluss | Phoebe Schluss |
 Nicole RichieLizzie Lennox | Lizzie Lennox |
 Will ArnettShamrock | Shamrock |
 Ken MarinoNikki Evans | Nikki Evans |
 Sterling SuliemanBen | Ben |
 Layla MohammadiCandace Nicaragua | Candace Nicaragua |
 Madeleine GuilbotYoung Erica | Young Erica |
 Oscar Daniel ReyezYoung Andy | Young Andy |
 Kennedi Lynn ButlerYoung Mikayla | Young Mikayla |
| TTeddy GatewoodYoung Josh | Young Josh |
 Jon GabrusPaul Dudley | Paul Dudley |