Set in the 1980s, a young Italian-American from the wrong side of the tracks falls for a Jewish girl from Long Island.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Spencer BoldmanGio Marchetti | Gio Marchetti |
 Emily RatajkowskiJessica Weintraub | Jessica Weintraub |
 Noah RobbinsAnthony Panagopoulos | Anthony Panagopoulos |
 Kathrine NarducciMama Fortunato | Mama Fortunato |
 Gino CafarelliPapa Fortunato | Papa Fortunato |
 Sebastian ManiscalcoDinardo | Dinardo |
 Theresa MoriartyStephanie | Stephanie |
| LLucas SalvagnoChris Carbone | Chris Carbone |
| PPeter GaudioVerducci | Verducci |
| AAl LineaTerry T | Terry T |
 Carmine FamigliettiVideo Vic | Video Vic |
| JJessie KomitorFrancesca's Friend | Francesca's Friend |
 Lauren Nicole CipolettiAngela | Angela |
| MMargaret FeganChris's Girl | Chris's Girl |
 Polly HumphreysDidi the Waitress | Didi the Waitress |
 Kachina DechertFlag Girl | Flag Girl |
 Jonathan WildeOfficer Grant | Officer Grant |
 Michael De NolaMr. Panagopuolos | Mr. Panagopuolos |
 Jen CohnMrs. Weinberg | Mrs. Weinberg |
 Josh Philip WeinsteinMr. Weinberg | Mr. Weinberg |
| MMichael MaugeriRandom Racer | Random Racer |
| JJonathon OlivoSick | Sick |
| QQuinn MeyersLou Fortunato | Lou Fortunato |