During her birthday celebration, Tess and Logan find themselves swept up in a world that isn't always what it seems when the headlining magician at the Magic Manor winds up dead.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lacey ChabertTess Harper | Tess Harper |
 Brennan ElliottLogan O'Connor | Logan O'Connor |
 Barbara NivenAunt Candace | Aunt Candace |
 John KapelosChief Chauncey O'Connor | Chief Chauncey O'Connor |
 Genevieve KangJosephine | Josephine |
 Steve BelfordReed | Reed |
 Noam JenkinsThe Amazing Alistair | The Amazing Alistair |
 Kaitlyn LeebBianca | Bianca |
 Paulino NunesRocco | Rocco |
 Matthew GouveiaCormac | Cormac |
 Cynthia PrestonJulia Marquez | Julia Marquez |
 Romaine WaiteWinston Sams | Winston Sams |
 Boomer PhillipsDelivery Man | Delivery Man |
 Will ShortzWill | Will |
 Chris HandfieldPaul Drexler | Paul Drexler |
 Nigel DownerDr. Cohen | Dr. Cohen |
 Milton BarnesCoroner's Clerk | Coroner's Clerk |
 Trudy WeissMaude | Maude |
 Jill FrappierTamara | Tamara |
 Darryl HindsAntiques Dealer | Antiques Dealer |
 Jim CalarcoLandlord | Landlord |