A crossword puzzle editor finds her life completely disrupted when several of the clues in her recent puzzles are linked to unsolved crimes, and she is pulled into the police investigation.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lacey ChabertTess Harper | Tess Harper |
 Brennan ElliottLogan O'Connor | Logan O'Connor |
 Barbara NivenAunt Candace | Aunt Candace |
 John KapelosChief Chauncey O'Connor | Chief Chauncey O'Connor |
 Victor A. YoungPierre | Pierre |
 Zach SmaduHarris | Harris |
 Genevieve KangJosephine | Josephine |
 Kelly PennerAlexander | Alexander |
 Anna HardwickElizabeth | Elizabeth |
| IIan MathesonAllan Nightingale | Allan Nightingale |
 Jonathan LangdonCarmichael | Carmichael |
| CCatherine McGregorVeronica | Veronica |
 Kathy MaloneyElaine | Elaine |
 Jewelle BlackmanM. Rappaport | M. Rappaport |
 James CadeJacob Morton | Jacob Morton |
 Chris FarquharJackson | Jackson |
 Jason BlickerDriver | Driver |
 Harris ShoreDetective | Detective |
 Will ShortzTable Tennis Player (uncredited) | Table Tennis Player (uncredited) |
 Kelsey RuhlWaitress | Waitress |
 Alexander NunezBarista | Barista |
 Vicki KimJane | Jane |
 Nadine WhitemanMad Woman | Mad Woman |
 Shane MarriottReporter | Reporter |
 Tyler DukeCop | Cop |