Nicole Borden, the owner of a quaint arts and crafts store "The Crafty Companion", is faced with an ultimatum when the owner of "Mitchell's Art and Craft Supplies" tells her she must either sell her store or be forced out of business.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jodie SweetinNicole Borden | Nicole Borden |
 Brent BaileyMathew | Mathew |
 Michael Patrick LaneEric | Eric |
 Maxwell CaulfieldAlfred | Alfred |
 Julie BrownAllison Garland | Allison Garland |
 Michael PerlLuke | Luke |
| DDonnaKelliCraft Buyer | Craft Buyer |
 Laura LongSarah | Sarah |
 Andrea Susan BushAngela | Angela |
| KKita Harrison GoldenChristine | Christine |
 Audrey LooyeJudith Worth | Judith Worth |
 Stephen WuJason | Jason |
| RRachel BinsfieldWaitress | Waitress |
 Emily EllsworthHostess | Hostess |