Based on Ann Rule's true crime book Practice to Deceive. In this New York Times Best Seller, a small, island community is turned upside down when Russel Douglas, a local businessman, is found dead the day after Christmas.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Diane NealPeggy Sue Thomas | Peggy Sue Thomas |
 Tahmoh PenikettJim Huden | Jim Huden |
 Tamara TunieDetective Williams | Detective Williams |
 April TelekJanice | Janice |
 Daniel BaconNeal | Neal |
 Lauren BradleyTeresa Liu | Teresa Liu |
 Daphne HoskinsSally Douglas | Sally Douglas |
 Richard KeatsJudge Cherkis | Judge Cherkis |
 Viv LeacockDetective Steadman | Detective Steadman |
 Adam LolacherMark | Mark |
 Paul McGillionRussell Douglas | Russell Douglas |
 Jill MorrisonBrenna Douglas | Brenna Douglas |
| CCorey TurnerSteven | Steven |
 Alison WandzuraJean Huden | Jean Huden |