The calls to Lindsay Mallyn's late-night, paranormal radio show are going from strange to stranger as the people of Circle City confront the supernatural in this Halloween-themed anthology.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lindsay LeckLindsay Mallyn | Lindsay Mallyn |
 Patty Najera-EsparzaSylvia Flores | Sylvia Flores |
 Julia LeslieMelody | Melody |
 Matthew RuinDerek | Derek |
 Samuel DumasThe Coil | The Coil |
 J.J. TaylorZack | Zack |
 Laura Morrison-RichcreekMelissa | Melissa |
 Liberty LeckThe Mysterious Girl/The Nursemaid | The Mysterious Girl/The Nursemaid |
 Jack DragaLes Moore | Les Moore |
 Brett WrightOwen | Owen |
 Dennis HanleyJohn | John |
 Hudson LeckJohnny | Johnny |
| TTessa JohnsonLucy | Lucy |
 Thomas QuinnGabe | Gabe |
 Maggie LeckThe Little Icky-Tricky | The Little Icky-Tricky |
 Stephen E. FoxworthyRev. Aiden Wright | Rev. Aiden Wright |
 TuckerCameron/Virgil Hobbs | Cameron/Virgil Hobbs |
 Lauren ShenPiper | Piper |
 J.P. LeckThe Circle City Collector | The Circle City Collector |