 Glenn FordYancey 'Cimarron' Cravat | Yancey 'Cimarron' Cravat |
 Maria SchellSabra Cravat | Sabra Cravat |
 Anne BaxterDixie Lee | Dixie Lee |
 Arthur O'ConnellTom Wyatt | Tom Wyatt |
 Russ TamblynWilliam Hardy, The Cherokee Kid | William Hardy, The Cherokee Kid |
 Mercedes McCambridgeMrs. Sarah Wyatt | Mrs. Sarah Wyatt |
 Vic MorrowWes Jennings | Wes Jennings |
 Robert KeithSam Pegler | Sam Pegler |
 Charles McGrawBob Yountis | Bob Yountis |
 Harry MorganJessie Rickey | Jessie Rickey |
 David OpatoshuSol Levy | Sol Levy |
 Aline MacMahonMrs. Mavis Pegler | Mrs. Mavis Pegler |
 Lili DarvasFelicia Venable | Felicia Venable |
 Edgar BuchananJudge Neal Hefner | Judge Neal Hefner |
 Mary WickesMrs. Neal Hefner | Mrs. Neal Hefner |
 Royal DanoIke Howes | Ike Howes |
 L.Q. JonesMillis | Millis |
 George BrenlinHoss Barry | Hoss Barry |
 Vladimir SokoloffJacob Krubeckoff | Jacob Krubeckoff |
| AAndy AlbinWater Man (uncredited) | Water Man (uncredited) |
| LLeon AltonTownsman at Celebration (uncredited) | Townsman at Celebration (uncredited) |
 Rayford BarnesCavalry Sergeant Who Breaks Up Fight (uncredited) | Cavalry Sergeant Who Breaks Up Fight (uncredited) |
| HHerman BelmonteDancer at Ball (uncredited) | Dancer at Ball (uncredited) |
 Mary BenoitMrs. Lancey (uncredited) | Mrs. Lancey (uncredited) |
 Barry BernardButler (uncredited) | Butler (uncredited) |
| PPhil BloomSettler (uncredited) | Settler (uncredited) |
| JJimmie BoothWagon Driver (uncredited) | Wagon Driver (uncredited) |
| DDanny BorzageTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
 Chet BrandenburgTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
 Janet BrandtMadam Rhoda (uncredited) | Madam Rhoda (uncredited) |
