| NNick MazzollaTony (Segment 1) | Tony (Segment 1) |
| VVeronica RojoJulie (Segment 1) | Julie (Segment 1) |
 Toni VitaleLinda Staunch (Segment 1) | Linda Staunch (Segment 1) |
 Danny BoushebelDeath (Segment 2) | Death (Segment 2) |
| LLogan Grace FinkelCecilia McGovern (Segment 2) | Cecilia McGovern (Segment 2) |
| BBrian Robert JonesFreddy (Segment 2) | Freddy (Segment 2) |
| JJeff RodmanRyan Schuster (Segment 2) | Ryan Schuster (Segment 2) |
| BBilly ToomaHomeless Man (Segment 2) | Homeless Man (Segment 2) |
 Deana EnochesDr. Evelyn Bower (Segment 3) | Dr. Evelyn Bower (Segment 3) |
| AAlexandra Petrova-EmistiSelene Stein (Segment 3) | Selene Stein (Segment 3) |
| MMelissa Rose JonesTV Show Host (Segment 3) | TV Show Host (Segment 3) |
| BBrad GoochSelf (Segment 4) | Self (Segment 4) |
| JJoe MifsudMarcus Johnson (Segment 4) | Marcus Johnson (Segment 4) |
| SSamuel PlatizkyDetective Stanford (Segment 4) | Detective Stanford (Segment 4) |
| JJeff RagsdaleDetective Brogan (Segment 4) | Detective Brogan (Segment 4) |
| MMatt RecchioneRay (Segment 4) | Ray (Segment 4) |
| CColleen SciaccaBrianna Johnson (Segment 4) | Brianna Johnson (Segment 4) |
| KKarolin ThomasLydia (Segment 4) | Lydia (Segment 4) |
| RRachel KaplanWincest Student #1 (Segment 5) | Wincest Student #1 (Segment 5) |
| SSarah KaplanWincest Student #2 (Segment 5) | Wincest Student #2 (Segment 5) |
| SSinan LoganDetective #1 (Segment 5) | Detective #1 (Segment 5) |
| KKarlo ToomaKenny Staunch (Segment 1) / Detective Tom Bryers (Segment 5) | Kenny Staunch (Segment 1) / Detective Tom Bryers (Segment 5) |