When relationship advice columnist Amalie Hess receives an unsigned love letter in a Christmas card, she returns to her hometown to solve the mystery of who sent it and maybe find true love.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Ashley NewbroughAmalie Hess | Amalie Hess |
 Tilky JonesIan McCallister | Ian McCallister |
 Chanté BowserDemi Jones | Demi Jones |
 Jackie PruchaMrs. Crabtree | Mrs. Crabtree |
 Ben VanderMeyJoseph Harrington | Joseph Harrington |
 Josh VenturaBruce | Bruce |
 Pierce LackeyWill Rivers | Will Rivers |
 Geraldine LeerKaren | Karen |
| IIzzy HerbertMarty McCallister | Marty McCallister |
| RRay BengstonRay Hess | Ray Hess |
 Adam ColeSander Monk | Sander Monk |
| CCharity HitchcockDottie | Dottie |
| DDenise HillisWaitress | Waitress |
 Damián RomayFisherman Dom | Fisherman Dom |
| SStacy Johnson(uncredited) | (uncredited) |