Benji is upset that he is playing the second shepherd in his school Christmas play for the second year in a row. But when Benji falls asleep while practicing his lines, his dream carries him and his dog Waldo to Bethlehem 2,000 years ago!
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Hans ConriedInnkeeper (voice) | Innkeeper (voice) |
 Don MessickWaldo / Joseph (voice) | Waldo / Joseph (voice) |
| RRichard SacinoBenji (voice) | Benji (voice) |
 Vic PerrinAdditional Voices (voice) | Additional Voices (voice) |
| CCharles PerrinAdditional Voices (voice) | Additional Voices (voice) |
 Jerry HausnerAdditional Voices (voice) | Additional Voices (voice) |
| DDavid JoyceAdditional Voices (voice) | Additional Voices (voice) |
| CColleen CollinsMary (voice) | Mary (voice) |
 Iona MorrisAdditional Voices (voice) | Additional Voices (voice) |
 June ForayAdditional Voices (voice) | Additional Voices (voice) |
| EElayne RobbinsAdditional Voices (voice) | Additional Voices (voice) |