Kara and Jessie are two teenage girls from very different worlds, but with a little Christmas magic, they find they have much more in common than they ever imagined.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Sierra McCormickKara Gentry | Kara Gentry |
 Brighton SharbinoJessie Wilkins | Jessie Wilkins |
 Bo DerekElsa Gentry | Elsa Gentry |
 Shelley LongJudy Wilkins | Judy Wilkins |
 Christopher RichBob Gentry | Bob Gentry |
 Joe Don RooneyJim Wilkins | Jim Wilkins |
 Tiffany FallonSherry | Sherry |
 Paula TrickeyIda Beth | Ida Beth |
 Christian KaneJeff Gentry | Jeff Gentry |
 Bryan WhortonRoy Wilkins | Roy Wilkins |
 Jasmine FontesAnalisa | Analisa |
 Betsy HumeGina Greystone | Gina Greystone |
| AAlex PrebleAshley | Ashley |
 Chris FreihoferJaret | Jaret |
| HHarvey LowryZachary | Zachary |
| DDavid Lee AndersonHomeless Man | Homeless Man |
 Mollie MilliganLady | Lady |
 Connie FranklinModeling Coach | Modeling Coach |
 J.J. ArendsRoy's Wife | Roy's Wife |
| NNick SwezeyWaiter / Greyhound Bus Driver | Waiter / Greyhound Bus Driver |
| MMaggie McClureBallroom Keyboard Player | Ballroom Keyboard Player |
| RRebecca BrookSanta's Helper | Santa's Helper |
 Becky BartlettLimo Driver | Limo Driver |
| HHannah SnyderLimo Driver | Limo Driver |
| BBryson SmithWesley | Wesley |