A skeptical writer shows up in Evergreen to get the scoop on the town's famed passion for Christmas during a search for a long-lost time capsule.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Paul GreeneBen Baxter | Ben Baxter |
 Maggie LawsonKatie Connell | Katie Connell |
 Barbara NivenCarol Shaw | Carol Shaw |
 Holly Robinson PeeteMichelle | Michelle |
 Rukiya BernardHannah Tucker | Hannah Tucker |
 Colin LawrenceThomas Tucker | Thomas Tucker |
 Ashley WilliamsAllie Shaw | Allie Shaw |
 Jill WagnerLisa Palmer | Lisa Palmer |
 Chris CopeEzra Green | Ezra Green |
 Michelle MartinMegan | Megan |
 Marlon KazadiDavid Tucker | David Tucker |
 Antonio CayonneElliot Lee | Elliot Lee |