 Deanna DurbinJackie Lamont / Abigail Martin | Jackie Lamont / Abigail Martin |
 Gene KellyRobert Manette | Robert Manette |
 Richard WhorfSimon Fenimore | Simon Fenimore |
 Dean HarensCharles Mason | Charles Mason |
 Gladys GeorgeValerie de Merode | Valerie de Merode |
 Gale SondergaardMrs. Manette | Mrs. Manette |
 David BruceGerald Tyler | Gerald Tyler |
 Eddie AcuffSteve (uncredited) | Steve (uncredited) |
 Fred AldrichBartender (uncredited) | Bartender (uncredited) |
 Frank AustinJury Member (uncredited) | Jury Member (uncredited) |
| JJohn BartonConcertgoer (uncredited) | Concertgoer (uncredited) |
| VVangie BeilbyWedding Guest (uncredited) | Wedding Guest (uncredited) |
 John BerkesWaiter (uncredited) | Waiter (uncredited) |
 Oliver BlakeDefense Attorney (uncredited) | Defense Attorney (uncredited) |
 Charles CaneJoe (uncredited) | Joe (uncredited) |
 Wheaton ChambersPlane Passenger (uncredited) | Plane Passenger (uncredited) |
 Ruth CherringtonConcertgoer (uncredited) | Concertgoer (uncredited) |
| JJames ConatyConcert Patron (uncredited) | Concert Patron (uncredited) |
 Heinie ConklinJury Member (uncredited) | Jury Member (uncredited) |
 Joseph CrehanSteve (uncredited) | Steve (uncredited) |
 Louise CurrieStewardess (uncredited) | Stewardess (uncredited) |
 Richard DaviesLieutenant (uncredited) | Lieutenant (uncredited) |
| NNeal DoddMinister (uncredited) | Minister (uncredited) |
 Eddie DunnJim (uncredited) | Jim (uncredited) |
 Jim FarleyJury Member (uncredited) | Jury Member (uncredited) |
 Clyde FillmoreColonel (uncredited) | Colonel (uncredited) |
 James FlavinPoliceman (uncredited) | Policeman (uncredited) |
 John HamiltonJury Foreman (uncredited) | Jury Foreman (uncredited) |
 Robert HomansPoliceman (uncredited) | Policeman (uncredited) |
 Arthur Stuart HullJury Member (uncredited) | Jury Member (uncredited) |
