When little Lucy wishes it were Christmas every day, "forever and ever", her dad tells the cautionary tale of her grandmother Tilly, who, as a little girl, made the very same wish, and the dire consequences that occurred after her wish was granted.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| SStacey MichaelsTilly / Cissy (voice) | Tilly / Cissy (voice) |
 Brian CummingsNed / Butcher / Policeman (voice) | Ned / Butcher / Policeman (voice) |
 Miriam FlynnHelen / Franny / Will (voice) | Helen / Franny / Will (voice) |
 Edie McClurgThe Christmas Fairy (voice) | The Christmas Fairy (voice) |
| MMarla FrumkinGracey / Lucy (voice) | Gracey / Lucy (voice) |
| DDick OrkinPapa (voice) | Papa (voice) |
 Nancy CartwrightLittle Girl (voice) (uncredited) | Little Girl (voice) (uncredited) |