While working on a class assignment to write a paper on “My Impossible Christmas Wish,” Olivia Mead quickly takes note of unusual happenings. As her wishes come true, she is convinced the miracles are linked to a mysterious woman she believes is an angel.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Della ReeseElsie Waybright | Elsie Waybright |
 Teri PoloMelinda Mead | Melinda Mead |
 Kevin SorboNathan Davis | Nathan Davis |
 Tamera Mowry-HousleyDaphney Conroy | Daphney Conroy |
 Lisa ArnoldMrs. Bell | Mrs. Bell |
 Bradley DorseySteve Dalt | Steve Dalt |
 Tyler HumphreyLucas Conroy | Lucas Conroy |
 Jaiden KaineJeb Conroy | Jeb Conroy |
 Toby NicholsBully / Classmate | Bully / Classmate |
 Izabela VidovicOlivia Mead | Olivia Mead |
 Rob BoltinMr. Brennan | Mr. Brennan |
| DDylan DePaulaClassmate | Classmate |
| NNatalie HultmanBecca Holloway | Becca Holloway |
 Brock Patrick KaufmanJoey Becker | Joey Becker |
| WWilliam J. WellsOrphan Ricky Sanchez (as William Wells) | Orphan Ricky Sanchez (as William Wells) |