 Sarah AgorKatie (segment "My BFF") | Katie (segment "My BFF") |
 Kimberly AtkinsonKim (segment "Dollface") | Kim (segment "Dollface") |
| AAri BavelBurt (segment "Get Off My Porch") | Burt (segment "Get Off My Porch") |
 Stephen BlackehartFrank (segment "My BFF") | Frank (segment "My BFF") |
| MMike BrabenderBearded Man (segment "Howl of a Good Time") | Bearded Man (segment "Howl of a Good Time") |
| SSally BremenkampWoman {segment "Get Off My Porch") | Woman {segment "Get Off My Porch") |
| SSteve BrewsterThe Gentleman (segment "Good Evening") | The Gentleman (segment "Good Evening") |
| JJessi BurketteThe Babysitter | The Babysitter |
 Sean CarmichaelDonnie (segment "Tickle") | Donnie (segment "Tickle") |
 Franco CastanArnold (segment "The Judas Cradle") | Arnold (segment "The Judas Cradle") |
| JJen DedeEmily (segment "Dollface") | Emily (segment "Dollface") |
| MMorgan CollarBrianne (segment "Howl of a Good Time") | Brianne (segment "Howl of a Good Time") |
 Leslie EasterbrookMartha (segment "Howl of a Good Time") | Martha (segment "Howl of a Good Time") |
| MMeagan FlynnDazed Neighbor 2 (segment "Get Off My Porch") | Dazed Neighbor 2 (segment "Get Off My Porch") |
| RRenae GeerlingsAmanda (segment "Howl of a Good Time") | Amanda (segment "Howl of a Good Time") |
 Tamara GlynnSimone (segment "Howl of a Good Time") | Simone (segment "Howl of a Good Time") |
| IIsla Parker HaleMary (segment "Howl of a Good Time") | Mary (segment "Howl of a Good Time") |
| ZZoe Sofia HaleAnne (segment "Howl of a Good Time) (as Zoe Hale) | Anne (segment "Howl of a Good Time) (as Zoe Hale) |
| DDennis J. HealyTic Tac (segment "Tickle") | Tic Tac (segment "Tickle") |
 Nick HolmesNick (segment "Dollface") | Nick (segment "Dollface") |
 Ty JonesNews Reporter (segment "Get Off My Porch") | News Reporter (segment "Get Off My Porch") |
 Chloë KerwinNot listed | Not listed |
| AAaron LaueDazed Neighbor 1 (segment "Get Off My Porch") | Dazed Neighbor 1 (segment "Get Off My Porch") |
 Chris LazzaroVinnie (segment "Howl of a Good Time") | Vinnie (segment "Howl of a Good Time") |
 John Edward LeeBelial (segment "The Judas Cradle") (as Johnny Lee) | Belial (segment "The Judas Cradle") (as Johnny Lee) |
| AAndrew LyndakerCharlie (segment "Tickle") | Charlie (segment "Tickle") |
| KKayla MadisonMadeline (segment "My BFF") | Madeline (segment "My BFF") |
 Roma MaffiaKaren (segment "Dollface") | Karen (segment "Dollface") |
 Katherine McNamaraMary (segment "Get Off My Porch") | Mary (segment "Get Off My Porch") |
| BBradley MeehanNeil (segment: "Get Off My Porch") | Neil (segment: "Get Off My Porch") |
