A peaceful community is forever changed when a mysterious young woman moves in. As the quirky locals embrace her, their lives soon improve. But, they can't help notice that their strange new neighbor has a secret.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Rachel BrosnahanWren Miller | Wren Miller |
 Aidan QuinnMoody Burkhart | Moody Burkhart |
 Seth GilliamOfficer Payne | Officer Payne |
 M. Emmet WalshWalter Lemke | Walter Lemke |
 Olympia DukakisMargaret Lemke | Margaret Lemke |
 Mary Beth HurtJo Ann Bayberry | Jo Ann Bayberry |
 Peter GeretyArnie Bayberry | Arnie Bayberry |
 Satya BhabhaJosh Kassouni | Josh Kassouni |
 Macy GrayDonna Olson | Donna Olson |
 Rachel Zeiger-HaagAlison | Alison |
 Ronald PeetStudent | Student |
 Phil NeeOlder Mailman | Older Mailman |
 Jonathan Randell SilverTroubled Person | Troubled Person |
 Gilbert CruzNeighbor Witness | Neighbor Witness |
| AAmorika AmorosoReceptionist | Receptionist |
 Sulekha NaiduPharmacist | Pharmacist |
| KKimberly L. JacksonNeighbor | Neighbor |
| EEric LockleyStudent | Student |
| YYohancé PrimusTeenager | Teenager |
| JJoe AloPolice Officer | Police Officer |
| JJuliet SchleferStudent | Student |
| JJames ZeissPolice Officer (uncredited) | Police Officer (uncredited) |