Teenagers are dying in their sleep, apparently from fright, the night before they have dentist appointments. A young teen elicits the help of his older brother to help him investigate the deaths, but soon find themselves in deep peril at the hands of a mad doctor and dentist.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Chase BolnickChad | Chad |
| MMatthew WoodwardZack | Zack |
 Jack CaronEddie | Eddie |
| BBrett GlassbergThe Dentist (as B. C. Glassberg) | The Dentist (as B. C. Glassberg) |
 Edward X. YoungThe Doctor | The Doctor |
| BBen SinekKenny | Kenny |
| SSam KasminNathan | Nathan |
| LLilah GrayceZack and Eddie's sister | Zack and Eddie's sister |
| JJay StoddartTooth Fairy | Tooth Fairy |
| JJay StoddartThe Tooth Fairy | The Tooth Fairy |