Tired of going out with beautiful but superficial and boring men, a young woman decides to try her luck with an unattractive janitor.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Linda CardelliniAdelle / Writer | Adelle / Writer |
 Jason SegelLeo | Leo |
 Brad RoweKen Doll #1 | Ken Doll #1 |
 Jack KyleKen Doll #2 | Ken Doll #2 |
 Jay JablonskiKen Doll #3 | Ken Doll #3 |
 Sam UptonKen Doll #5 | Ken Doll #5 |
| LLaura OtisWaitress #1 | Waitress #1 |
| MMaria de BrigardWaitress #2 | Waitress #2 |
| SShaziaBarbie Doll #1 (as Shazia Ali) | Barbie Doll #1 (as Shazia Ali) |
 Eva FrajkoBarbie Doll #2 | Barbie Doll #2 |
| AAlanna BoatrightBarbie Doll #3 | Barbie Doll #3 |
| RRenée GrahamBarbie Doll #4 | Barbie Doll #4 |
| RRachael SanthonBarbie Doll #5 (as Rachael Leigh) | Barbie Doll #5 (as Rachael Leigh) |
 David WeissKen | Ken |