A group of teenagers are haunted by a despicable act they committed when they were younger. Their actions caused the deaths of three innocent people. Now, on the anniversary of those deaths, an ominous calling card in the form of a carved pumpkin has been placed at each of their homes. Someone is out for revenge...the question is who?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| LLea DavisSophie (as Lea Falcione) | Sophie (as Lea Falcione) |
 Mark Ryan AndersonShawn | Shawn |
| AAlex TordiDustin | Dustin |
| AAdrian ArthurRodney | Rodney |
| EEmily Elizabeth CzerniakowskiChloe | Chloe |
| VVictoria BacciniAmy | Amy |
| DDavid ElijahJosh (as David Armanino) | Josh (as David Armanino) |
| BBrian Colin FoleyDean | Dean |
| SSasha GardeePenny | Penny |
 Hays WellfordSilas | Silas |
| RRobert Casey WilliamsYoung Shawn | Young Shawn |
| TTyler HentzYoung Dustin | Young Dustin |
| GGrace KubusYoung Chloe | Young Chloe |
| MMadison BaumgardnerYoung Amy | Young Amy |
| MMichael BulluckYoung Rodney | Young Rodney |
| MMark CollmerWendall | Wendall |
| BBuddy BlankenshipCoach Manson | Coach Manson |
 Elizabeth SaintClara Tyler | Clara Tyler |
| DDan MansonDan Manson | Dan Manson |
| CCyrus SamsonDJ Plasma | DJ Plasma |