 Jennifer GarnerLaura Pickler | Laura Pickler |
 Yara ShahidiDestiny | Destiny |
 Hugh JackmanBoyd Bolton | Boyd Bolton |
 Ty BurrellBob Pickler | Bob Pickler |
 Olivia WildeBrooke Swinkowski | Brooke Swinkowski |
 Alicia SilverstoneJulie Emmet | Julie Emmet |
 Rob CorddryEthan Emmet | Ethan Emmet |
 Ashley GreeneKaitlen Pickler | Kaitlen Pickler |
 Pruitt Taylor VinceNed Eaten | Ned Eaten |
 Kristen SchaalCarol-Ann Stevenson | Carol-Ann Stevenson |
 Phyllis SmithNancy | Nancy |
| GGarrett SchenckOrval Flanagan | Orval Flanagan |
| JJudy LeavellHelen Flanagan | Helen Flanagan |
 Joe ChrestButter Fan | Butter Fan |
| DDeana RicksButter Fan's Wife | Butter Fan's Wife |
 Kelly TippensMrs. Moore | Mrs. Moore |
 Dodie BrownJune Carmichael | June Carmichael |
| BBrett HillHayden | Hayden |
 Mark OliverMartin Caswell | Martin Caswell |
| CCindy CreekmoreDanielle Mattingly | Danielle Mattingly |
| JJeanne EvansMrs. Gunderson | Mrs. Gunderson |
 Corena ChaseMrs. Schram | Mrs. Schram |
 Jason YudoffAnnouncer | Announcer |
 Andy DalyRadio Announcer (voice) | Radio Announcer (voice) |
| HHeather CatesLaura's Fan (uncredited) | Laura's Fan (uncredited) |
 Gavin CasalegnoArt Class Student (uncredited) | Art Class Student (uncredited) |
| CChristine SchellerTransitional Home Worker | Transitional Home Worker |
| MMichael C. 'Mike' AllenCorporate Employee | Corporate Employee |
| JJennifer BentonCar Buyer | Car Buyer |
| CCharlotte BiggsState Fair Patron | State Fair Patron |
