After the events of the first film, a second Bull Shark begins feasting on unsuspecting victims in a Texas lake.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Billy BlairNolan Holt | Nolan Holt |
 Chad RidgelyMayor Williams | Mayor Williams |
 Thom HallumSpencer Timms | Spencer Timms |
 Tom ZembrodSheriff Wilcox | Sheriff Wilcox |
 Isabella OlivasSarah Smith | Sarah Smith |
| AAedin WaldorfChrissy Armstrong | Chrissy Armstrong |
 Andrea CohenLeslie Armstrong | Leslie Armstrong |
| DDylan BoehmTodd Peterson | Todd Peterson |
 Caden SmithGrant Timms | Grant Timms |
 Lindsey Marie WilsonDottie Time (uncredited) | Dottie Time (uncredited) |